Quick answer
No, the 25% rule comes from Florida, and neither Texas law nor San Antonio’s 2024 residential code has one. Here, repair or replacement depends on your roof’s condition and, after a storm, what your policy covers and your adjuster approves. Start with a free roof inspection from Apex.
If you’ve read that a roof has to be fully replaced once 25% of it is damaged, you’ve read about Florida. Below is where the rule came from, what does apply in San Antonio, and how to make the call on your own roof.
Where the 25% rule comes from
The rule is written into the Florida Building Code. Its existing-building section 706.1.1 says that no more than 25% of a roof or roof section can be repaired, replaced or recovered in any 12-month period unless the whole roof or section is brought up to the current code. For years, that meant a Florida homeowner with damage on more than a quarter of a roof often ended up with a full re-roof.
Florida narrowed the rule in 2022. Under Florida Statutes section 553.844(5), if a roof was built, repaired or replaced to the 2007 Florida Building Code or a later edition, only the part being repaired has to meet today’s code. The rule mostly survives now for older Florida roofs.
Because Florida roofers and insurers talk about it so much, the “25% rule” spread across the internet. Plenty of articles now describe it as if it were a national rule. It isn’t.
What applies in San Antonio instead
Texas law makes the International Residential Code the building code for homes in Texas cities (Texas Local Government Code section 214.212). Each city can adopt a newer edition with its own changes. The City of San Antonio adopted the 2024 codes on January 30, 2025, including the 2024 International Residential Code.
That code’s reroofing section, R908, explains how a new roof has to be put on. A roof replacement means removing the old layers down to the roof deck, and the deck and framing have to be able to carry the new roof. What it does not do is count damaged shingles or set a percentage that forces a full replacement. You can read the section in San Antonio’s 2024 residential code, chapter 9.
A full re-roof in San Antonio needs a city permit. Smaller repairs may not, depending on the work. Our guide to San Antonio building codes covers permits and inspections in more detail.
So who decides between repair and replacement?
Two things decide it: the roof itself and, if the damage came from a storm, your insurance policy.
The roof itself
A roofer looks at how old the roof is, how widespread the damage is, whether the decking underneath is still sound, how many leaks there are, and whether matching shingles are still available so a repair blends in. A young roof with damage on one slope is usually a repair. An older roof with damage on several slopes, soft decking or repeated leaks is usually a replacement. Our San Antonio roof repair page has a side-by-side table of these factors.
Your insurance policy
After hail or wind, your insurance company decides what it will pay for under the terms of your policy. The Texas Department of Insurance notes that some policies pay the full cost to repair a roof at current prices, while others pay less for an older or worn roof. No 25% figure in Texas law makes an insurer replace a roof, or stops it from paying for one.
What to do if your roof has storm damage
- Get a roof inspection first. Know what’s damaged before you call your insurer. Apex offers a free roof inspection with photos.
- Be there when the adjuster visits. The Texas Department of Insurance recommends being present and pointing out all of the damage.
- Compare bids with the adjuster’s report. Get more than one bid and check them against the adjuster’s list of damage before you settle.
- Pay your deductible. Texas law makes it illegal for a roofer to waive your deductible or offer a rebate to cover it.
- If you disagree, ask. TDI lists your options when you think the insurance company isn’t paying enough. In Texas, a public adjuster on your claim can’t also be your contractor.
Spring is San Antonio’s busiest stretch for hail. The National Weather Service Austin/San Antonio office issues the area’s severe thunderstorm and hail warnings, so a quick check after a warning in your part of town is worth it even when the roof looks fine from the yard. Our storm damage roof repair and roof insurance claims pages walk through the rest of the process.
Frequently asked questions
Does Texas have a 25% rule for roofs?
No. The 25% rule comes from the Florida Building Code. Texas cities use the International Residential Code, and San Antonio’s 2024 edition has no rule that forces a full replacement once 25% of a roof is damaged.
Can I repair just part of my roof in San Antonio?
Yes, when the damage is limited and the rest of the roof is in good shape. A repair should use matching materials and fix the cause, not just the visible damage.
Will insurance replace my whole roof if a few shingles are damaged?
That depends on your policy and what the adjuster finds. There’s no percentage in Texas law that decides it. If you disagree with the result, the Texas Department of Insurance explains your options.
Do I need a permit to repair my roof in San Antonio?
A full re-roof needs a permit from the City of San Antonio. Many small repairs don’t, but larger repairs can. Apex pulls the re-roofing permit on every replacement.
How do I know if my roof needs a repair or a new roof?
Look at the roof’s age, how many slopes are damaged, whether the decking feels soft, and whether leaks keep coming back. Apex checks all of this in a free 37-point roof inspection and gives you a written estimate for a repair or a replacement.
Not sure if your roof needs a repair or a new roof?
Apex Roofing & General Contractors gives San Antonio homeowners a free inspection and a straight answer, including when a repair is all you need. Call (726) 727-7663, visit us at 6414 W. Loop 1604 N, Ste. 210, San Antonio, TX 78254, or request a free estimate. If a new roof is the better choice, see our San Antonio roof replacement page.


